Steeping Black Tea

Black tea is the tea that forgives. It takes water at the boil, it takes a long steep without turning harsh, and it gives a full cup the first time. The reason is in how it is made, and knowing that makes its figures easy to remember and easy to bend.

How black tea is made

The plucked leaf is spread to wither for most of a day, until it is limp enough to roll without breaking. Rolling bruises the leaf and breaks its cells, and from then on the leaf oxidizes: the same browning that turns a cut apple, carried through to the end. The leaf goes from green to copper to near black in a few hours. Firing, a pass through hot air, stops the change and dries the leaf for keeping.

Full oxidation is what defines a black tea. It converts the sharp, grassy compounds of the fresh leaf into rounder ones, which is why a black tea tastes of malt, honey and fruit where a green tea tastes of the leaf itself.

Why the water boils

The compounds that oxidation makes are large and slow to dissolve. They need the heat of the boil to come out at all, and when they do they are soft on the tongue. The sharp, astringent compounds that cooler water protects in a green tea have already been changed in a black one, so there is little for the boil to spoil. Boiling water, then, gives a black tea its body, and a long steep deepens it. The usual range is three to five minutes: three for a bright cup, five for a full one.

One of our black teas is the exception. First Flush Darjeeling is picked in spring and oxidized only lightly, so the leaf keeps some of the character of a green tea. It takes 175°F (80°C) and three to four minutes, and at the boil it turns astringent.

Our black teas

  • Hermièlle Black, black teas from Sri Lanka and India blended to one standard: deep copper, bright, then full. Boiling water, three to five minutes.
  • Hermièlle Earl Grey, black tea with bergamot: the oil comes into the cup in the first minute, the tea follows. Boiling water, three to five minutes.
  • Hermièlle Decaffeinated, the same style of blend with the caffeine taken out before it reaches us. Steep it exactly as Hermièlle Black.
  • Yunnan, golden tips from the far southwest of China: smooth, sweet, a little peppery. Boiling water, three to five minutes.
  • First Flush Darjeeling, the spring picking from the Himalayan foothills: floral and light. Cooler water, 175°F (80°C), three to four minutes.

Minute by minute

The first minute brings the aroma. The second and third bring the body. The fourth and fifth round it out and add a little more strength. After five, a black tea adds only astringency, and the cup starts to dry the mouth. If a cup is wanted stronger than five minutes give, the answer is a second infuser, not a longer steep.

Two black teas, side by side

The two ends of the kind. Hermièlle Black is fully oxidized and built for the boil; First Flush Darjeeling is barely oxidized and asks for the water of a green tea. They are both black teas by the way they are made, and they could not be steeped more differently.

The second steep

A black tea gives a second cup, lighter than the first. Pour fresh boiling water over the same infuser and add a minute. The second steep of Hermièlle Earl Grey has less bergamot, since most of the oil came out the first time, and more of the tea beneath it.

The mistakes

  • Water off the boil. A black tea at 180°F stays thin and tastes of less than it is. Let the kettle finish, except for Darjeeling.
  • Lifting the infuser at one minute. The color is there but the body is not. Give it three.
  • Steeping past five minutes to make it stronger. It only gets drier. Use the shorter end of the range and a second infuser instead.
  • Milk before tasting. Our black teas are blended to be drunk alone. Taste first; milk suits Hermièlle Black if it suits the drinker.

In short

  • Boiling water, 212°F (100°C), for every black tea but First Flush Darjeeling, which takes 175°F (80°C).
  • Three minutes for a bright cup, five for a full one. Not longer.
  • A second steep from the same infuser, a minute longer.